SPECIAL FEATURE
Syncing Loops and Live Drums with Pro Tools and Live
By Brian Jackson

Digidesign ReWire plug-in routes Live's outputs into
Pro Tools.
Loops or live drums? It’s not an "either/or" choice anymore. With the editing and processing power of Pro Tools and related applications, keeping loops synced to a live performance is not just possible, it’s easy — for those who know how to do it, that is.

Every job has its tools, and for this task, we’ll use a remarkable third-party application in conjunction with Pro Tools: Ableton Live. Billed as a music-production solution for composing, recording, remixing, and editing musical ideas, Live is especially suited to loop-based composition. You can drag audio or MIDI files into a Live session in real time, allowing you to improvise and try things out on the fly, DJ-style.

Live can be synced to Pro Tools using Propellerhead Software’s ReWire technology, which allows you to stream audio from one application to another, send MIDI in both directions, and synchronize transport between apps. And since a special lite version of Live comes bundled with every new Pro Tools LE and HD system, you might already own it.

"Beat Detective analyzes an
audio file — for example, a drum
performance — and then allows
you to generate tempo maps
based on that file."
The other essential tools for this job live right inside Pro Tools. Beat Detective, Digidesign’s powerful editing application, is now available for LE systems with Pro Tools 6.7. And the new Graphic Tempo editor in version 6.7 makes it simple to draw and edit precise tempo curves in Pro Tools sessions, including nudging and trimming tempo segments.

Beat Detective analyzes an audio file — for example, a drum performance — so you can generate tempo maps based on that file. A tempo map is essentially a plot of all the \ subtle tempo changes in a performance, presented in the form of markers, which are then used as references for MIDI tracks or other synced applications to follow.

Even good drummers will speed up and slow down as they play, so creating a consistent tempo map is not as straight forward as defining the tempo of the overall performance. Each drum hit needs to be mapped so that loops (or, for that matter, MIDI tracks) can be locked into the same groove.

Get the Groove Going
The best way to illustrate this process is to do it step by step. Open a new Pro Tools session and create or import a stereo drum performance. Make sure the Tempo ruler is displayed in the toolbar at the top of the screen (to select this ruler, go to Display/Ruler View Shows/Tempo) and set your session timeline to Bars|Beats.

First, let’s create the tempo map. Select a region of the audio file in the Edit window. Since most loops are two bars long, I recommend making your selection a multiple of two. Next, open Beat Detective from the Windows menu and select the radio button next to Bar|Beat Marker Generation.

Before Beat Detective will work, you must click the Capture Selection button and then the Analyze button on the right. You still won’t see anything happening in your region, but don’t worry — Beat Detective is waiting for you to set the Sensitivity so that it knows what level of detail to work at. For this example, let’s use High Emphasis set to Sub-Beats so we can get all the details and nuances that our drummer put into the performance. For some performances, it may work just as well to define the tempo map every quarter-note or so.

Figure 1: Beat Detective in action dicing up a loop. Notice
the corresponding changes in the Pro Tools
Graphic Tempo editor.
Move the sensitivity slider over until there is a yellow line at almost every hit. (See figure 1.) These yellow lines are known as trigger points. If they’re set correctly you should see one at the transient (attack) of each drum hit. When you click Generate you will see blue arrows appear in the Tempo ruler (your new tempo map), and if you click the little arrow beside the Tempo ruler, you will see the Graphic Tempo editor. With the new Graphic Tempo editor it is very easy to use your editing tools to do some fine-tuning if needed.

ReWired and Ready
Let’s set up Live and Pro Tools to work in tandem via ReWire. There are a few different ways to work with ReWire audio streams. The easiest is to bring the audio in on an aux track. Create a new stereo aux input, insert the Ableton Live ReWire plug-in, and assign it to Mix L-Mix R. For this example, we’ll monitor all the tracks through Live’s master output. Alternately, you can create more aux tracks, insert more ReWire plugs, and then reroute each channel out of Live to the individual aux tracks. This is how you’ll probably want to do it when you’re ready to record your audio into Pro Tools.

Now we’re ready to fire up Live and start experimenting. Make sure you’re in the Session View of Live. (You can use the Tab key to toggle between Session and Arrangement views.) Ableton gives you 16 ReWire busses to choose from, which is plenty. Since we are monitoring all the audio through the master output, we don’t have to do any rerouting. Just make sure that the master out is set to the same output as the input you have set in the ReWire plug-in within Pro Tools.

Next, let’s load some loops into Live. Open the File Browser on the left side of Live’s screen. (If you can’t see the browser, click on the black arrow icon to open it.) Navigate to the loops that came with your version of Live and drag a few sounds into the audio tracks. (See figure 2.) You can also audition sounds in the File Browser just by clicking on them — just make sure that your Cue output is set to a destination you can hear (for example, the master output).

One of the great things about Live is its ability to handle functions in "Play." You can add and subtract parts and work out arrangements without ever having to hit the stop button. To hear how loops sound against your Pro Tools drum performance, just select the region in the Pro Tools Edit window, make sure Loop Playback is enabled and start the Pro Tools transport, then return to the Live screen to audition loops. As you preview or drag clips into the slots, they will automatically sync to the tempo map you’ve already set up in Pro Tools.

One of the coolest editing and processing functions in Live is "Warp Mode," which enables you to make subtle changes to the timing of a loop — or more drastically, alter the entire nature of a performance. For example, you can adjust a loop’s groove to make it lock in better with the drums in your Pro Tools session. Obviously some results will be more musical than others, but it’s worth taking the time to experiment.

Recording with ReWire
Ableton Live allows you to easily change the tempo
and feel of a loop.
Once you’ve selected some loops that sound great with your Pro Tools groove, you can record the audio stream from Live into an audio track in Pro Tools. Here’s how: First, create and name a stereo audio track in Pro Tools. Next, route the output of your existing Pro Tools aux channel — the one you’re using to monitor Live — to the input of the audio track via a stereo bus. Now when you record-enable the audio track, the stream from Live will show up in it. It’s that simple.

If you want to record each track from Live into its own track in Pro Tools, you have a little more routing work to do. It’s not difficult, but it takes a little time to set up. Instead of routing all of Live’s audio tracks to the master output and then into one aux, you can individually route each Live track into its own aux track in Pro Tools.

Here’s an example: Create and name three aux tracks in Pro Tools. Add a ReWire plug-in to each one and set each plug-in to a different stereo ReWire bus.

Next, in Live, change the outputs of each audio track to match the busses in Pro Tools: Go to the In/Out section of each track, and under "Audio To," choose ReWire. In the box below, choose the bus you want.

To finish the routing in Pro Tools, simply create and name three audio tracks to match the aux tracks, and route the outputs via the internal busses to the inputs of the audio tracks. Voila! Each audio track in Live now goes onto its own track in Pro Tools.

This is only one example of how Live and Pro Tools can be used together to take advantage of the strengths of both applications. Pro Tools and Live are both very deep applications, and the only way to master them is to spend some time with them. If you’re like me, finding the motivation to do so shouldn’t be an issue.

www.ableton.com
www.digidesign.com

Brian Jackson is an electronic musician with over eight years of Pro Tools experience under his belt. He teaches audio engineering at Touro College’s DMX program in New York City. Check out his website at www.form8.com